Chad: Overall, I just need to feel like I'm making more important decisions if I'm going to devote this much time to a game. If Shadows was a light, fluffy, 15 minute game, I'd be happy with the number of decisions invloved. But, as a game that takes 1.5 hours to play, making four meaningful decisions the whole game just leaves a foul taste in my mouth.

I'll agree that this game was sort of fun the first time or two I played it, and that the game will probably appeal to a lot of people. I also agree with Mike, however, that this one will quickly wear out it's welcome after about 5 plays or so.

Chad's rating: 4/10